Watch Ponies on KARE11 All Metro Teams
See footage of players who made the team dating back to 1987
Since 1987, Randy Shaver has produced a comprehensive All Metro Team to feature the best football players in the Twin Cities Metro Area.
Recently, he made every production available. The Stillwater Ponies feature 27 players, including two repeat performers, all of which can be viewed at KARE11 - All Time All Metro Teams or by clicking the names below:
| Year | Name | Position |
| 1987 | Jeff Nelson | Defensive Line |
| 1988 | Tommy Thompson | Quarterback |
| 1988 | Erik Holm | Running Back |
| 1988 | Darren Danielson | Tight End |
| 1989 | Jason Slavik | Offensive Line |
| 1990 | Steve Walters | Linebacker |
| 1991 | Pat Larson | Defensive Line |
| 1991 | Mark Holm | Offensive Line |
| 1992 | Mike Asmus | Defensive Line |
| 1992 | Kevin Klancher | Quarterback |
| 1993 | Chad Rogness | Quarterback |
| 1993 | Ray Wilhelm | Running Back |
| 1994 | Aaron Runk 1 | Running Back |
| 1995 | Nate Dwyer 1 | Defensive Line |
| 1995 | Ryan Pletcher | Defensive Back |
| 1995 | Aaron Runk 2 | Running Back |
| 1995 | Ben Beaudet | Offensive Line |
| 1996 | Nate Dwyer 2 | Running Back |
| 1996 | Adam Runk | Defensive Back |
| 1996 | Brad Putnam | Receiver |
| 1997 | Pete Zoller | Linebacker |
| 1999 | Paul Dexter | Linebacker |
| 2003 | Paul Fortman | Kicker |
| 2005 | Nick Branjord | Defensive Back |
| 2006 | Joe Stormont | Kicker |
| 2008 | Luke Dewall | Kicker |
| 2009 | Jeremy Gillard | Linebacker |
| 2010 | Andrew Rose | Linebacker |
| 2012 | Nate Ricci | Specialist |